THBT+caning+should+be+allowed+in+schools

Debaters:

1st Speaker - Calvin 2nd Speaker - Giresh 3rd Speaker - Musawwir

Reply Speaker - Alfian

Motion: THBT caning should be allowed in schools

Definition: School - Schools includes nurseries, pre-schools, primary, secondary and university. Children from ages 3 can also start school and end around 25 years old depending what the student take. Caning - an extremely severe punishment that should only be used as a last resort Baseline: Caning should not be made compulsory Onus: Us/Opp- As long as we prove that disciplinary action (caning) are not always needed at schools(sometims not needed at all) therefore does not have to be allowed, we would have served our purpose Prop- Must prove that caning is needed in **//__ALL__//** schools

Case Division: 1st Speaker -S1-Negative effects of caning. T1: offender T2: otheres around offender. 2nd Speaker -S1-Too harsh. T1: Physical pain is afflicted. T2: A lighter punishment like social service could be done.

Evidence: http://sgms.internet.gov.sg/search?q=caning&site=moe&feedback_url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.moe.edu.sg%2Ffeedback%2F&contact_url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.moe.edu.sg%2Fabout%2Fcontact%2F&client=default&proxystylesheet=default&output=xml_no_dtd

An IRS project was carried out and the majority said that pupils would react negatively to caning.

Do we have to state that caning should not be allowed at certain schools or caning should not be allowed in all schools?~Musawwir

Caning should not be allowed in all schools ~ Alfian